Skip to main content

Excess Slack Exists in Today's Labor Market

(PDF PDF icon)

First, the standard definition of unemployed workers excludes people who would like to work but have not actively searched for a job over the prior four weeks. They are considered out of the labor force and are sometimes referred to as discouraged or marginally attached workers. However, it is important to recognize that many people who become newly employed in a month were not actually out of the labor force in the prior month. So there is a significant amount of available labor in the pool of individuals not in the labor force that could and would enter the labor market if conditions improved.

Figure 1. Unemployment Rate

Unemployment Rate

Note: Shaded bars indicate recessions.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Second, people in part-time jobs who would like to work full time are not captured in the standard definition. These people are effectively underemployed, although not unemployed. While the Bureau of Labor Statistics does not make adjustments to its official unemployment rate to incorporate these situations, it does produce several alternative measures of labor utilization that do incorporate them.

The unemployment rate known as U-6 (really!) is the broadest measure of labor underutilization. It includes those workers who would like a job but are no longer actively searching for one, as well as people who are working part time but would rather be working full time. This broad measure of labor under-utilization rose from 8.2 percent in 2007 to 17 percent at its peak in 2009, and has since fallen to 14.5 percent.

Figure 2. Employment-to-Population Ratio

Employment-to-Population Ratio

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

This means that right now, roughly 22.7 million Americans want a job and do not have one or have a part-time job and would like a full-time position. A comparatively low 12.5 million individuals are included in the official (U-3) unemployment rate.

A look inside these numbers reveals that most of the difference between the official unemployment rate and this alternative definition is attributable to the part-time-worker category. There are 7.8 million part-time workers who would prefer and are available to work full time. Another 2.4 million people are out of the labor force and would like a job but have not searched in the prior four weeks.

The employment-to-population ratio is another useful measure for describing labor market conditions. This ratio measures total employment relative to the adult population. Since the start of the Great Recession, we have seen a large decline in this ratio, falling by almost 5 percentage points. We are now in territory last seen in the late 1970s and early 1980s, when women’s labor force participation rates were much lower.

The employment-to-population ratio hasn’t budged much from 58.5 percent since 2009. What this means is that the recent employment growth has only kept up with the growth in the adult population—holding the ratio roughly constant.

Although we should not expect the employment-to-population ratio to fully recover to its pre-Great Recession level because of our aging workforce, we should expect some cyclical rebound. The same patterns hold when looking at the employment-to-population ratio for prime age workers (ages 25 to 54)—little to no recovery.

The overarching conclusion is that all of these alternative measures of labor utilization show high amounts of labor slack in the economy. This sends a strong signal that we still have a relatively long way to go before the labor market recovers.

Upcoming EventsSEE ALL

  • 09.29.22

    Inflation: Drivers and Dynamics 2022

    Inflation: Drivers and Dynamics 2022, co-sponsored by the Center for Inflation Research and the European Central Bank will take place on September 29-30, 2022 in Cleveland, OH.

  • 10.06.22

    Conference on Real-Time Data Analysis, Methods, and Applications

    The Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland is sponsoring the Annual Conference on Real-Time Data Analysis, Methods, and Applications in Macroeconomics and Finance to be held in Cleveland, Ohio, at the Cleveland Reserve Bank on Thursday and Friday, October 6–7, 2022.

  • 11.07.22

    Women in Economics Symposium

    Join the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland at the Women in Economics Symposium, which aims to encourage women to pursue a career in economics by discussing the successful career paths of diverse economics professionals and raising awareness of diversity and inclusion in the profession.

  • 11.17.22

    2022 Financial Stability Conference: Frontier Risks, a New Normal, and Policy Challenges

    The Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland and the Office of Financial Research will host their 10th annual financial stability conference on November 17–18, 2022. This year’s conference is titled Financial Stability: Frontier Risks, a New Normal, and Policy Challenges.